By: Hutton Gibson
Defending the Faith of our Fathers, HERE...
Argument Corner
Objection—I think Bellarmine must be correct that a heretic ipso facto vanishes into his heresy, but this (ontological) fact is not manifest and notorious until the Church declares it a sorry fact. Bellarmine, while correct, likely did not foresee the consequences of his judgment. Suarez and Cajetan did, though they did not fully grasp Bellarmine’s truth. Thus a heretical Pope remains pope in the juridic sense (though he cannot bind us to error) and Christ supplies for the means of grace (Yes, even for the 1970 missal; only a hireling abandons the flock when the wolf comes) until either the clergy / people of Rome or a Council declares a Pope no longer Catholic. Only in this way is the stability, visibility, and means of grace of the Church maintained, even as we call the heretic back to the Faith a la the Abbe de Nantes, et al.... The Good Shepherd never abandons HIS flock to the wolves but supplies the means of grace during any deviation (Avignon), apostasy, or interregnum.
Reply—How do you explain the Moslem conquest, Orthodox schism, and Protestant revolt?
Can you ignore St. Paul’s Second Epistle to the Thessalonians, chapter 2?
It lies in the nature of a hostile takeover from the top that no effective group is left to defend religious doctrine or worship, though without these there can be no true Church. There should have been immediate revolt against change, but few, even of the clergy, realized what was happening (though a hundred thousand resigned). Those who protested applied for redress to those who had deliberately imposed change with the deliberate intention of killing the Church. The innovators ignored all protest. They stood on their “authority” and painted the few who kept tradition insane. They drove wedges between us and encouraged the “loyal opposition” with occasional crumbs that persuaded most that they would eventually return what they had stolen. But mostly they conveyed the notion that they had the right to improve on Jesus Christ, because only one fifth of the world was Catholic.
If we pin our hopes to the people or clergy of Rome, we appeal to those who have blindly accepted massive innovation. We should logically rather seek a declaration from the millions who have refused innovation, who are disgusted with weird worship and wall-to-wall heresy, and who boycott the remaining churches.
Pope Innocent III preceded Bellarmine by three and a half centuries in declaring that a heretic ipso facto vanishes into heresy. Pope Paul IV formulated this into law (Cum ex Apostolatus Officio) when Bellarmine was seventeen years of age.
Even if you were correct that instructed Catholics cannot assess a heresy, the innovators have publicly embraced condemned heresies galore, and this alone establishes that they are condemned heretics, which should be public enough for anyone.
It is impossible that the Catholic Church of Jesus Christ has no defense against a hostile takeover, from the top or from the bottom. When taken over from the top there is no possibility of an official statement condemning the takeover, because the entire top is involved in the takeover and will simply not condemn its own actions.
We therefore turn to right reason, and find all the authority we need in the Laws of the Church, specifically Cum ex Apostolatus Officio and the Canon Laws in which it is synthesized, #2314 & #188. These all state with authority that apostates and heretics can hold no office in the Church to which they cannot belong on account of their heresy and/or apostasy. The penalty immediately, automatically, and necessarily follows the fact itself of heresy or apostasy, and requires no declaration from any official source, as the law itself provides. We are all bound by these laws, and by Quo Primum Tempore which standardized our worship against the Protestant revolt, and must refuse recognition to “authorities” which violate them and saddle us with more recent idolatries.
The proof lies in recognition of the fact that the postconciliar “Church” has replaced almost the entire religion in its laws, doctrines, sacraments, and worship. It tries to speak with the authority which it has almost stamped out. It pretends to the authority which Christ conferred on His Church for propagation, which it has criminally discontinued.
HOW CAN THE CRISIS IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH BE ACCOUNTED FOR?
Showing posts with label Code of Canon Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Code of Canon Law. Show all posts
Sunday, November 22, 2009
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
The 917 Code of Canon Law Versus 1983 Substitute
Editor's NOTE:
I just received a copy of the 1917 Pio-Benedictine Code of Canon Law (English Translation with Extensive Scholarly Apparatus) by Dr. Edward N. Peters, Curator, Ignatius Press. He is an American trained civil lawyer and a Canon Lawyer as well.
Having just obtained my copy, I have no comments about it so far, but in the interim I include this short snippett below from Mr. Hutton Gibson who has written extensively on the subject of Canon Law. Included is a link to his web site where the interested reader can find the remainder of his article. I recommend reading it in its entirety.
--Dr. J. P. Hubert
The 917 Code of Canon Law Versus 1983 Substitute
By: Hutton Gibson
The Second Vatican Council could not impose innovation in the presence of the 1917 Code of Canon Law. So this Code was ignored and suspended while a friendlier code was fabricated by a commission that slithered to the hasty beat of a diffident drummer. Under the pretext of updating, faithless experts dropped or modified every law inconsistent with implementation of innovations of the Second Vatican Council or its omnipresent “spirit.”
Only a few laws remained, so the experts filled the gaps with piously poetic, modernist (heretical) concepts, needed only to enshrine innovation into law. Should anyone question an absurdity, he can be shown that it is the law of the Church.
This tactic is demonstrated often and at length in substitution of terms and definitions, which are short and to the point in the 1917 Code. In the canon laws on the sacraments you can see the initial definition (Canon 731) replaced in the 1983 joke with an irrelevant essay (canons 840-841) bearing little or no resemblance to law. MORE...
I just received a copy of the 1917 Pio-Benedictine Code of Canon Law (English Translation with Extensive Scholarly Apparatus) by Dr. Edward N. Peters, Curator, Ignatius Press. He is an American trained civil lawyer and a Canon Lawyer as well.
Having just obtained my copy, I have no comments about it so far, but in the interim I include this short snippett below from Mr. Hutton Gibson who has written extensively on the subject of Canon Law. Included is a link to his web site where the interested reader can find the remainder of his article. I recommend reading it in its entirety.
--Dr. J. P. Hubert
The 917 Code of Canon Law Versus 1983 Substitute
By: Hutton Gibson
The Second Vatican Council could not impose innovation in the presence of the 1917 Code of Canon Law. So this Code was ignored and suspended while a friendlier code was fabricated by a commission that slithered to the hasty beat of a diffident drummer. Under the pretext of updating, faithless experts dropped or modified every law inconsistent with implementation of innovations of the Second Vatican Council or its omnipresent “spirit.”
Only a few laws remained, so the experts filled the gaps with piously poetic, modernist (heretical) concepts, needed only to enshrine innovation into law. Should anyone question an absurdity, he can be shown that it is the law of the Church.
This tactic is demonstrated often and at length in substitution of terms and definitions, which are short and to the point in the 1917 Code. In the canon laws on the sacraments you can see the initial definition (Canon 731) replaced in the 1983 joke with an irrelevant essay (canons 840-841) bearing little or no resemblance to law. MORE...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
What/Where is the Roman Catholic Church?
In light of Traditional Catholic dogma/doctrine, how should the Second Vatican Council be viewed ? Is it consistent with Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition and prior Magisterial teaching?What explains the tremendous amount of "bad fruit" which has been forthcoming since the close of the Council in 1965? “By their fruits you shall know them” (Matt. 7:16)
This site explores these questions and more in an attempt to place the Second Vatican Council in proper perspective.